Is racism the price we pay for representation?

Is racism the price we pay for representation?

Tschabalala Self’s sculpture was vandalised by racists who painted her skin white – symbolically erasing exactly what it was intended to represent.

Haja Marie Kanu

3 min read

large bronze sculpture by Tschabalala Self looking out to sea

A Black woman on a chair. Towering over onlookers. Poised and yet relaxed. She asks, without any words, what does it mean to take up space?

Taking a seat is a universal act of leisure and calm. I wanted to create a monumental sculpture for the public that spoke to this simple joy. The woman is strong, beautiful and self-possessed. She represents all individuals, but women in particular, who understand the power and importance of gestures that assert their right to take up space.

Tschabalala Self

Seated was commissioned by Avant Arte, launching our public art programme. To begin with, it sat at bustling Coal Drops Yard near King’s Cross Station in London. This spring, the sculpture was moved to the De La Warr Pavilion, a contemporary arts centre in Bexhill-on-Sea, where she sits overlooking the English Channel. On May 15, the sculpture was vandalised by racists who spray-painted her white in an attempt to cover her dark skin.

Seated by Tschabalala Self looks to the sea outside the De La Warr Pavilion in East Sussex

The De La Warr Pavilion coordinated a community response to clean up the sculpture. Hundreds of East Sussex locals volunteered in a show of unity and solidarity. However, the artwork still needed professional restoration. Pilar Corrias, Tschabalala’s gallerist, responded as follows.

Obscene hate crimes like this demonstrate how much still needs to be done in the UK to fight racism, challenge discrimination and encourage diversity. As an artist exploring ideas about the black body (and predominantly female ones) Tschabalala Self’s work does just this. We laud Tschabalala and the De La Warr Pavilion’s gesture of involving the local community in the sculpture's restoration; significantly bringing people together in a positive act of resistance.

Pilar Corrias

Although the sculpture is inanimate, it is difficult not to interpret the act as one of racist violence. Tschabalala expressed her disappointment, but lack of surprise. It is a solemn reminder that bodies are political, space is political, art is political and Seated exists at this intersection.

Black, female – and especially Black female bodies – are often targets for abuse. Seated proudly represents the beauty of both blackness and femininity, and for these very reasons she has been harmed.

Tschabalala Self

Tshcabalala Self with her sculpture in London

As a Black woman, this is a reality that I reckon with every day. In 2019, I wrote a personal essay for gal-dem on my own experience of racism in the streets of London, The Politics of the Pavement. I explored the various micro-aggressions we experience as Black women simply daring to exist in public space and the histories that inform them. When I learned of the violence inflicted on the sculpture, I was reminded of truths I had stumbled upon myself by simply choosing to take up space.

Firstly, as minorities, taking up space is a right that we are repeatedly denied – physically, emotionally, and institutionally – in a world committed to our erasure. Secondly, the lack of education on the history and present of oppression in Britain allows these hierarchies to continue.

Tschabalala Self in her New Haven studio, wearing white and posing with a bronze sculpture and large yellow painting

Arts education can and should be part of that challenge to the status quo. For Avant Arte Chief Curator, Gemma Rolls-Bentley, who worked closely with Tschabalala throughout the project, it raises pertinent questions about curatorial responsibility.

Amidst necessary yet complex questions of representation, it’s important for curators and institutions to think carefully about what kind of responses artists are exposed to in the places where their work is put. This is most obvious, perhaps, when we consider art in the public domain. We can't ignore the reality that while some works are allowed to exist as isolated objects, others become symbols – targets, even – for the labels attached to their subjects and makers.

Gemma Rolls-Bentley

There is a risk involved whenever an artwork is exhibited in public. With access, we open ourselves to scrutiny, but racism seems a steep price to pay for representation. On the flip side, there is also a tremendous opportunity for dialogue and engagement with the history of the place in which an artwork stands.

Seated will reappear as an act of resistance, even greater for what she has overcome. She does not exist for the vitriol of a closed-minded few but for the many who felt seen by her.

It’s tempting to remember the schoolchildren who passed the sculpture each day in Coal Drops Yard – parking their scooters and dropping their bags to marvel at her – rather than the actions of one hateful individual. However, having witnessed the response of local and global communities, it becomes clear that what began as a violation is now a part of the artwork’s story too. No one asked for proof that we need big and beautiful artworks like Tschabalala’s in public life for all to see, but now we have it.

Gemma Rolls-Bentley

Go deeper

Co-directed by Tschabalala Self, a film by Olivia Lifungula invited Londoners to share their own perspective on the simple joy of sitting.

two teenage girls sitting on the floor, embracing

Watch: Stuart Hall Foundation’s series #ReconstructionWork hosted an event on Building Black Cultural Institutions.

Act: Make your voice heard in Visualise: Race and Inclusion in Arts Education – an ongoing research project by Runnymede Trust and Freelands Foundation.

Read: Revisit the unveiling of Tschabalala Self's sculpture.

Have thoughts?

Avant Essays are short(ish) opinions on art, written by anyone with an opinion on art. Have something to say? Get in touch.


More in this series

black and white photo of Yayoi Kusama and a horse, both covered in polka dots
essay

Yayoi Kusama Louis Vuitton: When Will The Dots Stop?

Bags, billboards and Bella Hadid. The commodification of Yayoi Kusama.

3 min read
Emily Xie: Plastic Code
essay

Emily Xie – Plastic code

Chinese-American artist Emily Xie’s coded creations replicate old world fabrics in new world media. Combining AI and generative methods, she asks what it means to be material in a digital world.

2 min read
Avant Essay, I feel like Pablo
essay

I feel like Pablo

Kanye West named Pablo Picasso as one of his role models, but the two of them have more than art in common. What do we do about our problematic faves? Can you separate the art from the artist?

5 min read
Avant Essay, The Guerrilla Girls
essay

The Guerrilla Girls: Four Decades of Disruption

From the streets to the Supreme Court, the punk feminist art collective are still fighting for social justice in the art world and beyond.

3 min read

Insightful?

Insightful?

Subscribe to the Avant Arte newsletter for the art world in your inbox.


Discover more insights

Photo of Thornton Dial standing with his art
00:55
video

Thornton Dial

American artist Thornton Dial became an international art world sensation at 60. He started his career many decades earlier, making toys out of junk. Today, he is considered one of the great artists of his generation.

INSA using a face filter
interview

INSA's collection

INSA is a self-described Graffiti Fetishist. Over his 15 year career, the anonymous artist has added his signature black and pink throw-up to walls, clothing and more recently NFTs. He’s also amassed an enviable art collection featuring works by legends like Murakami and ROIDS. His 'hunter-collector mindset' doesn’t stop at art, he spoke to Avant Arte about his 452 Gundam Robots, 2000 nudie lighters and the rocks that cover his house.

6 min read
black and white protrait of Ibrahim El-Salahi
00:59
video

Ibrahim El-Salahi

Ibrahim El-Salahi’s mesmerising paintings represent the dream of postcolonial Sudan. His prison drawings expose the nightmare hidden beneath.

2 min read
moma-ps1-i-love-you_thumbnail
article

PS1 I Love You

Happy 50th MoMA PS1! We trace five defining moments across five decades of New York’s most beloved museum.